In 1987, Steve Rothstein bought a $250,000 AAirpass from American Airlines, allowing unlimited first-class travel. He took over 10,000 flights, costing the airline $21 million, leading to the pass’s termination in 2008 due to alleged misuse.
“Does this man look like he’s had ALLL he could eat?”
“That could have been me!”
Sweet-Rayla
1 month ago
Misuse lmao, you really can never win against companies
CowntChockula
1 month ago
I assume “cost the airline $21 million” actually means the total retail price of the tickets he bought was $21 mil, not that they actually spent $21 million on the service for his flights.
Sustainable_Twat
1 month ago
American Airlines didn’t like him using the service he paid for?
GordieBombay-DUI-4TW
1 month ago
All you can eat means all you can eat.

Oli4K
1 month ago
It didn’t cost the airline 21 million. They didn’t make 21 million off of him. But he would never have made 21 million worth of flights because he would not have been able to afford that.
Mind-Your-Language
1 month ago

Jackieirish
1 month ago
So he didn’t just buy one pass. He bought his pass and a companion pass. Supposedly, he would then offer to take people using his companion pass wherever they wanted to go (I’m assuming for less than the cost of the airline ticket). He would also sometimes book the companion seat under a fake name to keep it vacant so he wouldn’t have to sit next to people or to store extra luggage (luggage rules were a lot looser back then). That was supposedly the misuse they cited as reasons for the revocation. He sued them. They sued him. Then they declared bankruptcy. Then they settled all the lawsuits out of court.
There was another guy who was also (supposedly) selling his companion seat that got his revoked, but that lawsuit is apparently still going.
BooeyNoine
1 month ago
Best r/doppelganger for Louis Litt
DickWoodReddit
1 month ago
Unlimited. You keep using that word. I don’t think it means what you think it means.
The AAirpass program sold 66 of the unlimited passes. As far as I can tell, only two were revoked by American Airlines for (alleged) misuse.
In Rothstein’s case, the airline alleged that Rothstein had a “*history of approaching passengers at the gate and offering them travel on his companion seat*” and would “*[use] the companion program to purchase an adjacent empty seat under a fake name to keep them vacant, which was often used for privacy or extra carry-on luggage.*”
BritishAnimator
1 month ago
^(*)Unlimited free travel forever^(*)
^(*with conditions and lawyers and BS)
ShrimpSherbet
1 month ago
That’s more than 1 flight per day each day for 21 years. Something about this is just wrong unless they’re counting companion flights too but still, it doesn’t really add up.
Healthy_Smoke_9514
1 month ago
My guy steve
14MTH30n3
1 month ago
I read that it was more cost effective for AA to open a department to specifically track when contracts were somehow violated and passes could be revoked.
afd83
1 month ago
Are their margins so thin that one person out of an entire flight would cost them too much money?
SssnakeJaw
1 month ago
Did they think someone was going to spend a quarter of a mil on something and not use it?
93195
1 month ago
Reminds me of the Simpsons episode with Homer and the all-you-can-eat seafood restaurant.
Treat it like a restaurant / hotel. Just fly when you feel hungry / tired
snozzberrypatch
1 month ago
10,000 flights in 21 years? That’s an average of 476 flights per year, or 1.3 flights per day, every day for 21 years. This dude must have really liked planes. You can’t even spend any time at the destination at that rate.
I’d say it’s plausible that this constitutes misuse…
ShouldaBennaBaller
1 month ago
Back when XFM and Sirius were two separate satellite radio services, my friend bought a lifetime subscription plan for XFM for like $150. Those companies merged and still honored that agreement. Thats been like 15 years ago and to this day I believe he still has a lifetime membership.
ZOLLINO
1 month ago
Isn’t that the same guy who on top of that earned thousands of fly points and sold them afterwards?
danydandan
1 month ago
What a hero.
Spaceman_Spoff
1 month ago
250k in 1987 is almost 700k in 2025. I’d say they didn’t “lose” anything
Fun-Chipmunk-2745
1 month ago
Misuse = using it? 🤣
Down_To_My_Last_Fuck
1 month ago
But you know those flights were running anyway, so it didn’t cost them shit. They just dint like to look stupid.
Scruffy_Nerf_Hoarder
1 month ago
Corporations when consumers try to get the most out of what they buy
DoughBoy_65
1 month ago
This amazes me how companies can get away with shit like this they should’ve thought of this before offering it to him and happily taking his $250k.
What if he died the next day would they have given his family back the money for unused services hell fucking no they wouldn’t !
That’s Louis, from suits.
“Does this man look like he’s had ALLL he could eat?”
“That could have been me!”
Misuse lmao, you really can never win against companies
I assume “cost the airline $21 million” actually means the total retail price of the tickets he bought was $21 mil, not that they actually spent $21 million on the service for his flights.
American Airlines didn’t like him using the service he paid for?
All you can eat means all you can eat.

It didn’t cost the airline 21 million. They didn’t make 21 million off of him. But he would never have made 21 million worth of flights because he would not have been able to afford that.

So he didn’t just buy one pass. He bought his pass and a companion pass. Supposedly, he would then offer to take people using his companion pass wherever they wanted to go (I’m assuming for less than the cost of the airline ticket). He would also sometimes book the companion seat under a fake name to keep it vacant so he wouldn’t have to sit next to people or to store extra luggage (luggage rules were a lot looser back then). That was supposedly the misuse they cited as reasons for the revocation. He sued them. They sued him. Then they declared bankruptcy. Then they settled all the lawsuits out of court.
There was another guy who was also (supposedly) selling his companion seat that got his revoked, but that lawsuit is apparently still going.
Best r/doppelganger for Louis Litt
Unlimited. You keep using that word. I don’t think it means what you think it means.
Lawyer up
[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AAirpass#Pass_terminations](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AAirpass#Pass_terminations)
The AAirpass program sold 66 of the unlimited passes. As far as I can tell, only two were revoked by American Airlines for (alleged) misuse.
In Rothstein’s case, the airline alleged that Rothstein had a “*history of approaching passengers at the gate and offering them travel on his companion seat*” and would “*[use] the companion program to purchase an adjacent empty seat under a fake name to keep them vacant, which was often used for privacy or extra carry-on luggage.*”
^(*)Unlimited free travel forever^(*)
^(*with conditions and lawyers and BS)
That’s more than 1 flight per day each day for 21 years. Something about this is just wrong unless they’re counting companion flights too but still, it doesn’t really add up.
My guy steve
I read that it was more cost effective for AA to open a department to specifically track when contracts were somehow violated and passes could be revoked.
Are their margins so thin that one person out of an entire flight would cost them too much money?
Did they think someone was going to spend a quarter of a mil on something and not use it?
Reminds me of the Simpsons episode with Homer and the all-you-can-eat seafood restaurant.
[All You Can Eat](https://youtu.be/1kzb6uf0U0k?si=QyZw8LBruaK_1S-a)
Treat it like a restaurant / hotel. Just fly when you feel hungry / tired
10,000 flights in 21 years? That’s an average of 476 flights per year, or 1.3 flights per day, every day for 21 years. This dude must have really liked planes. You can’t even spend any time at the destination at that rate.
I’d say it’s plausible that this constitutes misuse…
Back when XFM and Sirius were two separate satellite radio services, my friend bought a lifetime subscription plan for XFM for like $150. Those companies merged and still honored that agreement. Thats been like 15 years ago and to this day I believe he still has a lifetime membership.
Isn’t that the same guy who on top of that earned thousands of fly points and sold them afterwards?
What a hero.
250k in 1987 is almost 700k in 2025. I’d say they didn’t “lose” anything
Misuse = using it? 🤣
But you know those flights were running anyway, so it didn’t cost them shit. They just dint like to look stupid.
Corporations when consumers try to get the most out of what they buy
This amazes me how companies can get away with shit like this they should’ve thought of this before offering it to him and happily taking his $250k.
What if he died the next day would they have given his family back the money for unused services hell fucking no they wouldn’t !